COMPOSITIONS: CRITICAL REACTIONS
This exquisite opera deserves repeated outings.
-Daphna Levit, on I will fly like a bird, Opera Canada, Fall 2015
The next two songs on the album, each by John Plant, are the stand-out works of the group. Sunday at 4 am, for which LeBlanc performs with the Blue Engine String Quartet, opens with a short passage for the quartet in harmonics followed by an extended vocal solo written without text. This vocal solo sets the mood for the remainder of the work, which unfolds brilliantly through a constantly-changing development of musical material. Plant’s approach to the string quartet and voice as an ensemble is delicate and sensitive, and the performers expressed that sensitivity well. Plant’s second song, Sandpiper, begins with more energy than anything before it...- Justin Rito, I Care If You Listen, October/November 2013, review of 'I am in need of music' Centrediscs CMCCD 191413
.. This reveals a major talent that deserves to crop up in international recitals... 2001’s La notte bella is a fascinating setting of Giuseppe Ungaretti, scored for piano, violin, and cello. The sparse text... is set to soaring melodic lines before the strings turn this soulful piece into something more shivery and frenzied. Plant gives himself a bigger canvas for Romance sonámbulo, a 20-minute semi-cantata, set to one of Lorca’s Gypsy ballads. With the mournful, funeral brass writing, sparing use of Sprechgesang, and fretful tension conveyed in the strings, Lorca’s bleak, unsettling tale of a smuggler returning to find his lover dead is masterfully told. ...Loud atonal clusters open the chilling 'In the world of zero'... (Plant) is that rarest of modern composers, someone who writes sympathetically for the voice. His word setting is similarly impeccable ...This must not just stay in the Canadian music scene.
-Barnaby Rayfield, Fanfare, January/February2011, review of CD 'Vocal Works in Eight Languages by John Plant'
The composer has the task of shaping a coherent musical structure to that narrative. It seems that only the really great vocal composers bring it off: Brahms, Mahler, Wagner, Strauss, Stravinsky, Mussorgsky, Vaughan Williams, Debussy, Fauré, Britten, Barber, and so on. Plant succeeds in every item here.
First, Plant's literary taste is not only impeccable, but shows a fellow who reads widely and deeply. Babel is a blessing uses texts in Alexandrian Greek, Latin, Italian, French, Spanish, German, Russian, and English. ...If I had to compare him to another composer, I'd say Barber, especially the Barber of the extended vocal works: Dover Beach, Knoxville, and Andromache's Farewell. There's that same integrity of vocal line and an essentially Romantic outlook without eschewing the grit of dissonance and the ambiguous key center. Three poems get settings ranging from ten to nearly twenty minutes. It takes real control to keep something that long together. My favorite setting was probably of Lorca's Romance sonámbulo. Plant takes advantage of textual repetitions to suggest ballad structure within something essentially organic form. The point is, however, that it does have form.
Most of the performers, including the composer himself at the piano, do really well. The songs sweep along….. Jocelyne Fleury's voice reminded me of the incomparable Jennie Tourel …
-Steve Schwartz, Classical.net
With a regard for language that is purely metaphysical and a skill in handling words musically which is uniquely his own, John Plant has selected music he has written in memoriam. It is an inspiring sampling of music... The music shares a predilection for crystalline textures and harmonies that space out briefly before trailing wistfully away. Yet each eventually attaches itself to the poetry and takes on an asymmetrical emotional life and a faint cultural accent, perhaps mythical. At the end, "In the world of zero," Plant's sad resignation finally gives way to rage punctuated with violent drum beats and elusive woodwind accents..'
-Laurence Vittes, Gramophone, July 2010, review of CD 'Vocal Works in Eight Languages.'
(Romance sonámbulo) John Plant nous propose une musique colorée et mordante... - -Claude Gingras, La Presse, 18 June 2006
(Shadowy Waters) M. Plant sait écrire, cela est sûr. Il fait bien sonner ses percussions, harmonise efficacement ses cinq voix. -Claude Gingras, La Presse, 1 March 2005
“Extraordinary...Plant’s setting of this poem (Canciones del alma) succeeds in transcending limits of musical style to give articulation to experiences which are almost beyond the realm of language, verbal or musical...John Plant, a composer who has a significant message for our time. 9/10
-Wolfgang Bottenberg, Montreal Mirror, 20 January 2000
“Canciones del Alma” est un essai en musique minitieusement conçu.. austère et exigeant, d’une rare authenticité.”
-P.M. Bellemare, La Scena Musicale, December 1999
"The Collector of Cold Weather illustre une bonne douzaine de poèmes de Lawrence Raab .. sur une texture musicale de John Plant, qui depuis What Happened est devenu plus debussyste que jamais. Gentiment tiraillé entre le voyeurisme, l'humour, l'hu-mort, la mort, l'oeuvre fait rire, fait écouter. Que demander de plus d'un spectacle? ...Et sur du Debussy légèrement schoenbergisé, mille et une choses se passent ... C'est un spectacle. Un vrai. D'aujourd'hui."
-Jean-Jacques van Vlasselaer, Le Droit, 10 0ctober 1980
(What Happened) "Partition interessante que cette structure musical qui trace à un second niveau le jeu de la langue de Ms. Stein. Cet étudiant de George Todd,de Charles Palmer et de Bruce Mather a de la technique, une approche fraiche, sait être versatile, sait mettre en valeur les danseurs ... autant que le texte .... Les interludes enregistrés au piano emploient des themes reliés les uns aux autres et qui se retrouvent tous dans celui qui precède le dernier acte. John Plant a de l'admiration pour George Crumb et Luciano Berio: le sourire musical qui passe dans la partition et la technique vocale le révèlent ... l'oeuvre n'arrête pas de plaire.
-Jean-Jacques van Vlasselaer, Le Droit, 6 October 1978
(Une danse maigre pour trois voleurs) ".. a fascinating musical score by John Plant.. an astringent and oddly refreshing work..." -Myron Galloway, Montreal Star, 9 Jan.1975
(Marche sur glace) "La partition de piano de John Plant est translucide comme une voile." -René Picard, Le Devoir, 18 January 1975
( Une danse maigre pour trois voleurs ) ...une magnifique musique pour deux voix de femmes de John Plant ... -René Picard, Le Devoir, 9 January 1975